I would totally believe that especially regarding any lateral switch, I was simply trying to understand Mcburneys post which seemed like he was referring to application of ICS on all incidents vs the difference in culture and which one is more difficult to adapt to.
But I’d be guessing if that’s what he meant or not. I also attribute my experience to truly being blessed with strong overhead everywhere I’ve worked, not saying every employee/supervisor however, solid individuals at each work station to use as a mentor or backstop to limit failures and boost success.
I’ve been lucky throughout my career as a fed as well as Cal Fire and I put everything I have into passing that mindset onto my guys, that’s the only way I see us coming out of all these changes with our heads on straight.
It seems every year I see more individuals and younger individuals occupying overhead assignments on teams or just acting as overhead at campaign fires during fire season while they have 1 season or less experience fighting fire on those same type of incidents.
So in short my biggest gripe is you can have a FF1 spending a good portion of the fire season working overhead or a brand new FAE doing the same thing and then shortly being eligible to promote and lacking the real experience needed to act under these high risk low frequency events.
Not sure why I got on that soap box it just came out.